• undergroundoverground@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    4 days ago

    My point is very much that it’s inescapably obvious in basket ball and I disagree that a gene lotto trumps training every time in ALL sports. There’s darts bowling and snooker, even before we consider that Messi isn’t particularly genetically gifted and neither is Harry Kane.

    I don’t mean to single basketball out and I feel the same for sports where wealthy people have a huge advantage too. I mean, you or I could’ve been world dressage or polo champions if we were born to people rich enough to own horses and large amounts of land.

    • Not_mikey@lemmy.dbzer0.com
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      4 days ago

      I guess Steph Curry would be the equivalent of Messi, he’s not freakishly tall, and even looks rather short on the court compared to all the other 7 foot tall freaks, but he’s still 6’3" (~2m) and taller then 90% of people. Both were at a time considered the best at their sport.

      Same probably with Messi, the genetic gifts are harder to quantify then height, but he’s probably in the 90th percentile genetically of thigh strength or foot dexterity or something.

      Genetics also determine fine motor skill to an extent as well. I played hockey for years and even though I put the same effort in there were just people who shot better then me. It’s just harder to quantify and see but the best people at darts, bowling, golf, snooker etc. probably also possess some innate unseen advantage that puts them above the rest.

      • undergroundoverground@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        4 days ago

        But who the genetic freak equivalent in football? Even if that was true about messing, which it isn’t (he just played football nonstop from the age of 3, had incredible coaches and never stopped training) how does that explain the others like Harry kane? As someone who studied genetics, I think you’re putting far too much emphasis on genetics for those sports. I couldn’t out compete a semi pro football player by being 7 ft 8.

        • TAG@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          3 days ago

          Look at the Japanese team from the World Cup. They had an unbreakable defense but did not get very far in the knockout stage because their players were too short to stop high headers.

          • undergroundoverground@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            2 days ago

            They don’t have and have never had an unbreakable defence. They simply came up against a better team than them. Ümit Davala also had a free header (as in unchallenged and with nothing to put him off) on goal which has nothing to do with height but positioning, cross accuracy and poor Japanese defending. More so, japans centre backs are the same height as Davala. Makin up that they went out due hight is genuinely a wild thing to try and justify. You made up that I said basket ball is all about height. Then you’ve made this up too. What is going on here?

            • TAG@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              1 day ago

              I was talking about how Japan was eliminated in the game vs. Brazil.

              From what I remember, in the first half, Brazil came out trying to attack the Japanese defense and got nowhere. Brazil tried bringing more and more players until the Japanese got an easy goal on a counter attack. Then the Japanese really locked down on defense, only sending one player forward when they got a counter attack, in hopes of getting a second goal via dumb luck.

              In the second half, Brazil just stopped trying to kick the ball at the Japanese goal, since they could not get close enough to get a high probability shot. Instead, the Brazilians sent a couple tall, jumpy strikers into the box and sent a tall cross that only their forwards could get. The first couple of times, it was an easy catch for the goalie, but one got past to tie the game. Since that seemed to be the only thing that was working for Brazil, they kept trying it, in desperation. Meanwhile, Japan put together some very good attacks, none of which quite managed to score, but required the Japanese to send multiple players forward. Finally, deep into stoppage time, the tired Japanese midfield lost a Brazilian player who got a clean shot and a winning goal.

              The Japanese only made a single fatigued slipup all game. If they had had enough height and jumpiness to defend headers in the box, they could have spent the entire second half sitting back on their side and never gotten tired. Even if that last minute error was inevitable, it would have only tied up the game.

              • undergroundoverground@lemmy.world
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                edit-2
                1 day ago

                I think you might be reaching for something that isn’t there. Brazil aren’t a particularly tall team and the average height of the Japanese team is 5ft 11. Edit: the average height of the Brazilian team is 6ft. One inch on average isn’t going to make any material difference in the air.