• petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    2 days ago

    You’re not reading between the lines. I’m arguing with an anti-natalist, not someone who had a hysterectomy.

    Try thinking about this for a moment, okay: What emotional state do you think a person might need to have to also fantasize about letting humanity, of which they are a part of, burn out completely?

    Now compare: A person is having too much fun traveling the country and doesn’t think now, if ever, is a good time for having kids. Truthfully, they’re not sure they even want them.

    • 5318008@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 day ago

      Okay, I thought about it… and this is still wrong:

      Because these are the same thing.

      I’m telling you why what you said is wrong. ssfckdt could be criminally insane, and it wouldn’t make you any less wrong. Your wrongness has nothing to do with the emotional state of the person you responded to.

      I’m arguing with an anti-natalist

      I understand. You’re wrong in this context. It’s still possible for you to be wrong, even if you’re disagreeing with someone else who is also wrong. By telling you that you’re wrong, I’m not making any claim about what ssfckdt said.

      • petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        1 day ago

        Yes, it does. Advocating for the end of reproduction to… “save” the planet? is a suicidal impulse, same as trying to hasten the conditions for the rapture to happen would be. This is death cult behavior.

        • 5318008@lemmy.ml
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          edit-2
          18 hours ago

          Yes it does what?

          Whether or not you’re wrong depends on the emotional state of the person you’re responding to, “Yes it does”?

          Whether or not telling you that you’re [edit: wrong] implicitly makes a claim about ssfckdt’s statements, “Yes it does”?

          Neither of those work. Maybe you meant something else?

          Advocating for the end of reproduction to… “save” the planet? is a suicidal impulse

          See the previously outlined difference between scenario A and scenario B. Those are not equivalent. Do they become equivalent if everyone does that at the same time? No.

          They’re not the same. That’s just a fact; I don’t know what else to tell you.

          • petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone
            link
            fedilink
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            23 hours ago

            The first one.

            Honestly, I don’t think you’re equipped to have this conversation, man. You don’t seem to understand much of what I mean by suicidal, like, at all.

            Can we try something? Can you explain to me in your own words what it is you think my position is? Like, you don’t agree with it, clearly, but why am I saying the words that I’m saying?

            Why is it that I am so fixated on this idea that anti-natalists—I’ll be more careful with my language here—represent a suicidal, self-destructive, pessimistic and hopeless ideology and worldview?

            • 5318008@lemmy.ml
              link
              fedilink
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              edit-2
              18 hours ago

              The first one. [Whether or not you’re wrong depends on the emotional state of the person you’re responding to, “Yes it does”?]

              Okay, well that’s not true.

              Scenario 1:

              ssfckdt emotionally, angrily, and frenetically says that the sky is pink. You respond that the sky is green. You’re wrong.

              Scenario 2:

              ssfckdt calmly and rationally makes a case that the sky is pink. You respond that the sky is green. You’re wrong.

              Scenario 3:

              ssfckdt emotionally, angrily, and frenetically says that the sky is blue. You respond that the sky is green. You’re wrong.

              Scenario 4:

              ssfckdt calmly and rationally makes a case that the sky is blue. You respond that the sky is green. You’re wrong.

              Your correctness or your wrongness depends only on what you said, not the emotional state or the correctness or wrongness of the person you’re responding to.

              Can you explain to me in your own words what it is you think my position is?

              I think your position is imprecise, based on your gut feelings about the topic. I think it’s similar to the way that most people think “consensual gay sex between adult brothers is wrong” even though they aren’t able to explain why. I think that no matter how I articulate your position, you will have some other belief which contradicts that articulation. Then there is nothing that I can say which is completely correct. The best I can offer is themes:

              You believe that suicide is bad.

              You believe that human extinction is bad.

              You believe that individuals choosing not to have children is acceptable.

              You believe that everyone choosing not to have children is bad.

              You believe that “I enjoy being here” is a valid counterargument to antinatalism, for reasons that we have not managed to unpack, yet.

              You stated that Antinatalism is “the same thing” as Individual Suicide, but we have not managed to unpack exactly what you believe based on this statement.

              You believe that the truth values of your statements depend on the emotional state of the other people in the conversation, for reasons that I am still trying to understand.

              Why is it that I am so fixated on this idea that anti-natalists represent…"

              Because focusing on the flaws in other people’s statements allows you to ignore the possibility that you have also made mistakes in your own statements.

              • petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                link
                fedilink
                arrow-up
                1
                ·
                3 hours ago

                When you’re arguing about people’s motivations, the things they think and feel are actually the most important. This is what separates manslaughter from first degree murder. This is how you know when you’re being ghosted whether a person dislikes you, or actually is just busy.

                You believe that “I enjoy being here” is a valid counterargument to antinatalism

                Oh, that’s easy. I was being catty.

                That was me accusing them of being unhappy, which actually isn’t that difficult to pick up because either they are very, very unhappy, which only means I’ve struck a bullseye; or, their antipathy for other people comes from a… I dunno, the leftist curse of being able to see the iceberg we’re drifting towards, which means they could be happy, but they’ve also still got to contend with their own mortality, all of which serving to make the words “I am happy” just that much more difficult to say.

                Of course, I think this is ridiculous. I can say them easily: I am happy. Uh, Ocarina of Time came out recently, that was really fun. I think that the world should stop doing global warming, and wars, and rapes, and shouldn’t fizzle out also, uh, because I like Ocarina of Time.

                Antinatalism is “the same thing” as Individual Suicide, but we have not managed to unpack exactly what you believe

                Minor correction: you haven’t. That is what I am still here for. That’s the only reason I’m willing to write so much right now.

                You decided at some point that what I meant was “sticking a gun in your mouth.” That isn’t what I meant. I was always, the whole time, talking about their disposition, their attitude, towards life. A bad attitude leads people to make bad decisions. Bad policy decisions, maybe. Suicidal ones, broadly. Poetically, if you will.

                If you’re thinking that you’ve caught me, I’m now doing a Motte and Bailey, I’m not. Anti-natalism is a suicidal worldview. You will simply have to meditate on this until the light breaking through the clouds finally enlightens you on what this means.

                Because focusing on the flaws in other people’s statements allows you to […]

                C’monnn, that seems a bit anti-intellectual. That makes me think that you’re an anti-natalist, 5318008.

                • 5318008@lemmy.ml
                  link
                  fedilink
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  edit-2
                  43 minutes ago

                  You decided at some point that what I meant was “sticking a gun in your mouth.” That isn’t what I meant. I was always, the whole time, talking about their disposition, their attitude, towards life.

                  That is a reasonable interpretation based on this part of the exchange:

                  ssfckdt:

                  What I find weird here is that I was talking about ending reproduction, and you somehow interpreted that as individual su*cide. Like, if you don’t reproduce, you cease to exist? Huh?

                  You:

                  Because these are the same thing.

                  You could have, at any time, clarified this by making your language more precise, rather than doubling, tripling, and quadrupling down on an analogy that I’ve repeatedly pointed out is not a good analogy. Hence my comments about how your position is imprecise and based on your gut feeling.

                  Additionally, this clarification is STILL not supported by any actual argument. This is just an assumption you’re making about what would motivate a person to hold a belief, when 1: No one espoused this explicitly as their motivation, and 2: There’s no a priori requirement that someone hold this disposition prior to holding this belief.

                  Minor correction: you haven’t. [as opposed to “we”]

                  This is not a correction. “You haven’t” is simply more specific than “we haven’t” in this context, since this usage of “we” requires that both of us do a thing rather than either of us. This does not matter for either of our points, but I think it’s on theme for you to attempt a pedantic correction, and for me to describe the logical structure of why it’s not a correction. We’ll add it to the pile of logical errors.

                  I’m now doing a Motte and Bailey, I’m not.

                  Well, now I just think you’re bad at describing your thoughts. Again, this corresponds to the imprecision of your position. A Motte and Bailey would be if you were doing this on purpose… but I don’t think your position is even well-specified enough for that.

                  That makes me think that you’re an anti-natalist

                  You can think anything you want for any reason you want. I think the reason you gave is silly. I think most of what you’ve said so far is silly. I’m pretty much just doing this for as long as I can find hidden little logical exercises, because that is the only thing of value to me, here.

                  • petrol_sniff_king@lemmy.blahaj.zone
                    link
                    fedilink
                    arrow-up
                    1
                    ·
                    27 minutes ago

                    I’ve repeatedly pointed out is not a good analogy

                    It’s actually a great analogy. You, also, just dislike the way it sounds.

                    “You haven’t” is simply more specific than “we haven’t”

                    Since you seem to like words and definitions so much: “we” would be incorrect because I have already unpacked it. I am eating a slice of pizza at the finish line, waiting for you to catch up to me. Have you ever thought about trying to explain color to a blind person?