I mean what is up with this whole genre? It seems like a waste of time.
Terrible lore (an LLM could’ve done better) Difficulty of the sake of difficulty.
Hard games peaked with “I wanna be the guy” in 2007
I mean what is up with this whole genre? It seems like a waste of time.
Terrible lore (an LLM could’ve done better) Difficulty of the sake of difficulty.
Hard games peaked with “I wanna be the guy” in 2007
I can explain this! Gaming has always been hard, at least since the NES. Games were hard because they had to be small (with the exception of, say, Final Fantasy), so most of your action/adventure games could honestly be run through in a few hours. The world record for Super Mario Bros. 1 is something like 4:54. That’s minutes and seconds, and while, yes, it does utilise warp zones, it’s pretty crazy. Games had to push back against the player to make you feel like you didn’t waste your money.
Super Nintendo games were a little easier as the market tried to balance. Nintendo 64 and especially PlayStation leaned into harder games — the former because Super NES games were easier, and PlayStation because it marketed itself toward more mature players.
When Dark Souls came onto the scene, the iPhone accounted for a majority of gaming, and gaming was more like Subway Surfers, Temple Run, and Jetpack Joyride. Games that were free were only difficult enough to get you to spend money and no more. This environment is why FromSoftware decided to make their games so hard. No easy mode. Unforgiving enemies. Controls that weren’t like other games, that made you learn their game as opposed to them conforming the controls, and ultimately most of the game, to what you expect. They forced you to get… er… “git gud” as the other commenter said.
Dark Souls wasn’t the first game to really be hard, though. Halo and Gears of War were offering plenty of challenge for those who asked for it. The difference was, Dark Souls only had its “hell hard” difficulty. They took away the option to play on easy, medium, or even hard. “This is our game and this is how it is meant to be played.” For players who already took the highest difficulty option… well, it was still hard, because you had to learn their game system. Your reflexes from literally any other game would not help you. All that was by design.
That said, I don’t like them either. I’m not a kid with nothing to do but play video games. I work over 40 hours a week. I have other stuff to do. For most games, I put them on story mode. If they’re good enough for a second go-round, I’ll turn the difficulty up next time, so it’s not a cake walk once I already know what to do and where to go. But it’s not my default. Any game that leans Souls-like gets a pass from me. These aren’t the kinds of games that interest me.
The Souls games aren’t even hard, they are challenging enough to be satisfying to me. I’ve only played DaS1-3 but they’re not nearly as time consuming as something like Path of Exile and they’re not as easy to mess up your build and necessitate a restart like PoE either.
Fromsoft overhyped the difficulty in marketing DaS: Prepare to Die in order to appeal to a worldwide audience and that stuck around as a meme, like OP’s post imo 👀
That’s a fair point. I never actually put that together.
Ive played/beaten all the darksouls/demonsouls/elden ring game(s) and definitely “got good” but it was mostly just a challenge of learning each fight and preparing.
Overall i couldnt of spent more than 1k hrs in them.
PoE on the otherhand has several thousand hours of my time and it is by far a ‘harder’ game in a general sense of the word.
You dont need quite as much reaction and control skill but do need a metric shit ton of general game knowledge unless you want to follow a guide.
Learning enemy movesets is far easier than understanding wardloop for example. Or even just maintaining memory of the entire passive tree. Having the reaction time to execute on your memory is more challenging than being able to recall several build defining uniques and making a shell for a build when you see a new skill gem.
Also i think people get defensive and prideful of dying and seeing it as losing. The only way you lose in a game with unlimited lives is by giving up, or deciding it’s not worth your time. (And if you decide its not worth your time, then its not really losing since youre freeing yourself of it)
Anyway uhhhh. the new league is fun
I’ve never seen anyone shorten it like that
Wait you’re telling me that the janky control scheme for dark souls is…on purpose?!!
Oh god. I always thought it was just not enough user testing.