I mean what is up with this whole genre? It seems like a waste of time.
Terrible lore (an LLM could’ve done better) Difficulty of the sake of difficulty.
Hard games peaked with “I wanna be the guy” in 2007
I mean what is up with this whole genre? It seems like a waste of time.
Terrible lore (an LLM could’ve done better) Difficulty of the sake of difficulty.
Hard games peaked with “I wanna be the guy” in 2007
I will try to explain from my own personal experience. As a disclaimer, nothing here should be taken as any attempt to be superior in any way. Hating on roguelikes and souls-style games is a-okay in my book - they’re not for everyone.
I look at these games as ‘fun’ in the same way as assembling a puzzle, building a gunpla model, or beating your best jogging time are also ‘fun’.
There are different gamer archetypes and I’m pretty clearly in the ‘achiever’ bracket. I like a tough challenge and the feeling of completion that comes from that. Meanwhile, I’m getting absolutely savaged by a piece of software that tests the limits of my patience, anger, and mental endurance. In fact, these games have actually helped me with controlling anger and frustration under duress; once I noticed I was playing consistently worse while flustered, everything started to change.
At the same time, I absolutely see what FromSoftware is about. These games, going all the way back to Demon’s Souls, have been messy, disjointed, cobbled-together affairs. Each game ships with experimental game mechanics, some that we still use today and some that never get revisited in future games. The art and regions are kinda smashed together into a kitbash world of wildly different zones, many with unfair platforming and environmental hazards. There are skill cliffs (e.g. “vigor checks”) that are only surmountable with grinding or locating super-secret items. Then there’s the “invasion” mechanics. Story-telling is at times brilliant, and other times “it do be like that” with hardly an explanation. And so on. Overall, it’s less about a carefully balanced and cohesive world, and more about having just enough stuff in the game for the player to not consistently die on all the rough edges.
The only thing that renders “fairness” is the almost complete lack of RNG in monster attacks, movements, and placement, yielding a predictability that can be learned and planned against. At the same time, it’s cold comfort at best.
So, these things are a absurdly challenging hot mess to play and I feel like I beat the odds whenever I eke out a victory. It’s a little fucked up, but I kinda like it.
I wouldn’t put rogue-like in the same bucket.