At the point when someone engages in that kind of intellectual dishonesty, I think it’s fair to go with the philosophical nuclear option and point out that the entire concept of ontology is founded on and limited by epistemology. If they’re going to use dirty tricks to pin you, it’s okay to dive into the ravine leading to solipsism.
I was once talking to some chud in Reddit (where else) and I noticed they were clearly having problems defining their own argument in an unambiguous way. So I broke out formal logic and tried to define the statement more rigorously and asked the statements defined that way matched the intent they had behind them.
Now, my formal logic knowledge was pretty rusty (I think it was briefly covered in school and it was covered a little bit in 1st year computer science), but I was apparently completely overqualified anyway, because this person started yelling something about librul witchcraft symbols or something. …despite that particular crowd being supposedly so into STEM stuff, they seem to be somewhat ill equipped to handle it. Can’t even handle a few ∃s and ∀s. Buncha weaklings, the lot of them.
That all looks like it would be kinda fun to take a class on, but I’m an engineer and had to look up all of that. The only formal logic symbols I learned in school were logic gate symbols, and I don’t use them enough to not need to look them up.
That said, if someone brought all that into a discussion I could use Wikipedia to rephrase it into something I understand
I reccomend taking a class on it if you can! I’ve never felt more special and more like a unique genius than when I finish a lightly unintuitive logic proof… on the homework that everyone else had to do too.
In math, we’re actually encouraged to avoid using the quantifier symbols and to write out “there exists…” or “for all…” because it’s more readable. I think that in a natural-language argument using the symbols is a bit unnecessary and gatekeepy.
To be perfectly clear, what I did back then was straight up chain-yanking. Mild trollàge, one could say.
But yes, improving accessibility to scientific text is a worthy cause.
Of course, the chud audience would see improving accessibility to scientific text as yet another piece of “DEI” nonsense. “What? Make scientific texts accessible for all? No! The more incomprehensible they are, the better!”
Well nowadays they could just refine/wash their argument through an LLM to arrive at something more cogent. I’m left to conclude that really stupid arguments are just a skill issue with an insanely low bar to clear - it’s just people telling on themselves.
At the point when someone engages in that kind of intellectual dishonesty, I think it’s fair to go with the philosophical nuclear option and point out that the entire concept of ontology is founded on and limited by epistemology. If they’re going to use dirty tricks to pin you, it’s okay to dive into the ravine leading to solipsism.
Using big words is ablist.
You actually made me laugh out loud. That is a well-crafted and succinct comment.
Nobody outside their niche bubble cares about what “philosophers” of our era think or say.
I was once talking to some chud in Reddit (where else) and I noticed they were clearly having problems defining their own argument in an unambiguous way. So I broke out formal logic and tried to define the statement more rigorously and asked the statements defined that way matched the intent they had behind them.
Now, my formal logic knowledge was pretty rusty (I think it was briefly covered in school and it was covered a little bit in 1st year computer science), but I was apparently completely overqualified anyway, because this person started yelling something about librul witchcraft symbols or something. …despite that particular crowd being supposedly so into STEM stuff, they seem to be somewhat ill equipped to handle it. Can’t even handle a few ∃s and ∀s. Buncha weaklings, the lot of them.
I would have become so giddy if someone whipped out ∃s and ∀s in a conversation with me
That all looks like it would be kinda fun to take a class on, but I’m an engineer and had to look up all of that. The only formal logic symbols I learned in school were logic gate symbols, and I don’t use them enough to not need to look them up.
That said, if someone brought all that into a discussion I could use Wikipedia to rephrase it into something I understand
I reccomend taking a class on it if you can! I’ve never felt more special and more like a unique genius than when I finish a lightly unintuitive logic proof… on the homework that everyone else had to do too.
It is truely one of life’s most pure feelings.
In math, we’re actually encouraged to avoid using the quantifier symbols and to write out “there exists…” or “for all…” because it’s more readable. I think that in a natural-language argument using the symbols is a bit unnecessary and gatekeepy.
To be perfectly clear, what I did back then was straight up chain-yanking. Mild trollàge, one could say.
But yes, improving accessibility to scientific text is a worthy cause.
Of course, the chud audience would see improving accessibility to scientific text as yet another piece of “DEI” nonsense. “What? Make scientific texts accessible for all? No! The more incomprehensible they are, the better!”
Well nowadays they could just refine/wash their argument through an LLM to arrive at something more cogent. I’m left to conclude that really stupid arguments are just a skill issue with an insanely low bar to clear - it’s just people telling on themselves.
Man, I don’t like Disney, but I love Disney comics…