I do agree that it’s an issue, but part of “you have the freedom to update when you want” is “you have the responsibility to update”.
I think that a lot of folks running Linux distros, which normally give a user control over updates, are more techie types. Yeah, you’re going to update because you don’t want your system exposed to compromise.
But Windows is kinda the default in offices, and you have people out there who are going to just see updates as a pointless nuisance and given the opportunity, won’t ever update.
An added wrinkle is that Unix file semantics normally permit an open file to be replaced. Windows file semantics normally do not. This means that on Linux, update systems can often update running software underfoot, and it will just start working next time it’s launched. On Windows, the update system normally forces a reboot or restart of software so that the files can be modified with the software not running. That interruption is also disruptive.
The flip side is that some software, like Firefox, does not deal well with being updated while running and may malfunction if done so until restarted (these days, I think that Firefox detects an update and forces the user to restart it itself). I suspect that that misbehavior could be confusing to some users.
I agree based on the principle: “The most popular OS in the world should update automatically.” Granted, the most popular OS should not be Windows, and the workflow should be better. But many people obstinately want to never update windows and never give it periods to update on its own.
There IS genuinely a user fault to the issue, even if MS isn’t handling it great. They deal with a lot of stupid customers.
But many people obstinately want to never update windows and never give it periods to update on its own.
And significant amount of those people should be able to do it. I have a windows machine that I use for some work-related stuff and other odd stuff that still doesn’t run on Liniux. It’s behind firewall, it doesn’t have anything important on it, and I have a full disk image, so if anything happens to it, I just restore it to a clean state with no hesitation.
I don’t need it to be smart about updates, I don’t give a shit what microsoft thinks is important for me to have on my computer, and I especially don’t give a shit what changes they made to their llm-powered spytech or whatever the fuck they’re trying to sneak in with every update. If I want to update something I will do it, on my own, as an owner of my computer, not when some llm in Microslop offices decides.
Assuming a firewall does anything. It prevents unexpected external connections, but most major security events come from accidentally executing code through a common use application like a web browser.
“If anything happens to it”, you likely won’t know. Smart hackers don’t pop a big “Hah! You’ve been hacked!” banner. They’re more likely to run spyware or zombie scripts, or just leave a backdoor open for months for some future plan or to observe for some opportunity. Plenty are smart enough to find sysrestore volumes and infect those.
Just like with human medical viruses, it’s not just your own problem, and it could affect far more than just you. When a big DDOS attack happens to your favorite site, that is often driven by thousands of aforementioned zombie computers. Not only does MS not want that, no one does - hence why even the FBI will put out large advisories for people to update their shit (even routers can become zombies).
If your PC is completely air-gapped, I don’t think anyone will care much. Otherwise, consider how it’s used. As boring as it is to say, the default setup grandma gets with her Dell is often the safest way to go (up until she clicks that popup).
I set my grandpa’s Mint to update automatically with backup on boot, one could probably set it in offices. No idea hpw hard it’d be for multiple computers, though.
I do agree that it’s an issue, but part of “you have the freedom to update when you want” is “you have the responsibility to update”.
I think that a lot of folks running Linux distros, which normally give a user control over updates, are more techie types. Yeah, you’re going to update because you don’t want your system exposed to compromise.
But Windows is kinda the default in offices, and you have people out there who are going to just see updates as a pointless nuisance and given the opportunity, won’t ever update.
An added wrinkle is that Unix file semantics normally permit an open file to be replaced. Windows file semantics normally do not. This means that on Linux, update systems can often update running software underfoot, and it will just start working next time it’s launched. On Windows, the update system normally forces a reboot or restart of software so that the files can be modified with the software not running. That interruption is also disruptive.
The flip side is that some software, like Firefox, does not deal well with being updated while running and may malfunction if done so until restarted (these days, I think that Firefox detects an update and forces the user to restart it itself). I suspect that that misbehavior could be confusing to some users.
I agree based on the principle: “The most popular OS in the world should update automatically.” Granted, the most popular OS should not be Windows, and the workflow should be better. But many people obstinately want to never update windows and never give it periods to update on its own.
There IS genuinely a user fault to the issue, even if MS isn’t handling it great. They deal with a lot of stupid customers.
And significant amount of those people should be able to do it. I have a windows machine that I use for some work-related stuff and other odd stuff that still doesn’t run on Liniux. It’s behind firewall, it doesn’t have anything important on it, and I have a full disk image, so if anything happens to it, I just restore it to a clean state with no hesitation.
I don’t need it to be smart about updates, I don’t give a shit what microsoft thinks is important for me to have on my computer, and I especially don’t give a shit what changes they made to their llm-powered spytech or whatever the fuck they’re trying to sneak in with every update. If I want to update something I will do it, on my own, as an owner of my computer, not when some llm in Microslop offices decides.
A number of mistakes here.
If your PC is completely air-gapped, I don’t think anyone will care much. Otherwise, consider how it’s used. As boring as it is to say, the default setup grandma gets with her Dell is often the safest way to go (up until she clicks that popup).
I set my grandpa’s Mint to update automatically with backup on boot, one could probably set it in offices. No idea hpw hard it’d be for multiple computers, though.