
the fifth freedom is the freedom to own humans, apparently š
(no, i am not making this up. yes, someone asked gnu maintainers if hypothetical code oritinating from slave labour would be fine to contribute. yes, these fucks answered YES without hesitation.)
From the emacs-devel mailing list (Archive). Was about to post this myself. The world deserves such a better free software movement than the one these guys have built.
I hope the Human Emacs fork goes ahead, because I love Emacs too much to give it up.
This meme is actually my response to that discussion. Eight slaves and constantly swapping? Maybe edit.com isnāt so bad.
thank you for the source!
I understand the overall argument. Iām not 100% sure of how well this argument fits with not doing anything about LLM contributions, but OK. You donāt want to add too many goals to your already established group or that could easily create fracturing between its members. If everyone sticks to a single goal, old members wonāt complain about the group changing direction in ways they donāt agree with, the group might bring more people in (because anyone that agrees with that single goal might want to contribute), and the resources wonāt be spread thin.
Claiming to accept contributions that result from slavery is way fucking beyond that though. I donāt know about you, but Iād expect that every group I work with would at the very fucking least agree to follow the goddamn Universal Declaration of Human Rights. And in the GNU Foundationās particular case, Iād also expect them to do it, especially with them having being founded is the US, the country where the UN is headquartered.
Also, is it just me, or do the GNU Foundationās leaders keep forgetting how to be human? This is far from the first time theyāve said stupid stuff like this.
What the fuck? Like, no discussion or explanation of their rationale, just āmust be YESā as if thatās obvious? Come on⦠Free software really shouldnāt be Slave Labor GNU/AI Slop Linux.
Thereās so much public attention on the enshittification of everything in computing and growing momentum around free software alternatives⦠I do wish the people behind big free software projects would not say this sort of shit.
the screenshot cuts off the next paragraph:
Any other answer is a first step towards splitting our community along the many lines of political and ideological divides that have nothing to do with software freedoms. Right now we have contributors from all over the world, despite the differences in their regimes and political systems, differences in ideologies, and even in the very interpretation of the notion of āfreedomā. You are suggesting to subject the contributors to some examination of the principles they uphold, the ethics of their day-to-day activities, their views on matters of policies and important international events, etc. This will immediately fracture our community into many different enclaves. And thatās exactly my point, and the main reason why I must reject the āHuman Emacsā initiative, as it is presented to us.
i donāt like this argument as i reject nationalism (while accepting geographic self-determination) but it seems most people agree with nationalism, so iād like to hear othersā thoughts on this.
You might enjoy Davi Ottenheimerās take in GNU Maintainer: Slave-Made Code? āYESā.
Wollstonecraft answered the divisiveness claim even more clearly in 1790. Burke had argued that inherited institutions must stay beyond ethical examination, because a society that judges its own foundations fractures. Her reply applies to āfracture our community into many different enclavesā word for word: āthe whole tenor of his plausible arguments settles slavery on an everlasting foundation.ā In her second edition she spelled out the consequence. On Burkeās reasoning, āthe slave trade ought never to be abolished.ā
Sounds familiar, no?
A rule that forbids ethical examination of provenance protects whatever provenance is already inside the system. That held for sugar. It holds for emacs.
that is indeed pretty much what i think, thatās nice! it seems to me that without the pretty important part of geographic self-determination, nationalism in its entirety is an inherited institution of prejudice
That is wild, but I guess not totally surprising given the ethical implications of AI.
This sort of mentality is why Linus thinks āLinux isnāt politicalā is a rational statement. FLOSS is great, the dudes in it have long been not.
āIām apoliticalā is literally a political stance, making such a person political
why wouldnāt the answer be yes?
Because itās horrendously unethical and utterly awful to coƶperate with slavers.
First, there is the Isāought problem, in which an observation that the GPL is compatible with code originating from slave labor or AI is magicked into the moral imperative that such code must be accepted.
Iād just like to interject for a moment. What youāre refering to as Slop, is in fact, GNU/Slop, or as Iāve recently taken to calling it, GNU plus Slop. Slop is not art unto itself, but rather another free-ish component of a fully functioning GNU artpiece [ā¦]
Me just giving up on having a PC - giving it to my younger sibling till new hope will catch me. 'Cause letās be honest: name me one ok, privacy respecting, non-slop, relatively easy to use and supported OS currently (preference on debloated). So Iāve just accepted that my moral is in the way.
Letās just wait on either GNU/Linux2 or a good NetBSD based one (not counting AlpineBSD when it comes out).
Linux right now is easy to use as long as you donāt need to do anything advanced specialised with it. I switched a few months ago and was actually a bit disappointed, because it was too simple.
macOS has some AI bloat that is completely isolated from the rest of the system, so it fits all of your non-preference requirements
also, i donāt use emacs, so i see no problem with using the rest of GNU/Linuxā¦








