Ok so i haven’t read this anywhere; purely thought of it myself. I want to know whether it’s correct.
I think that planets cannot form simply out of a hydrogen/helium gas cloud. The reason is because for a small gas cloud, the internal pressure drives the gas apart, but the gravity is not strong enough to pull it together, so it drifts apart.
For a very large gas cloud, the force of gravity that pulls it together, is larger than the internal pressure that pushes it apart; so it forms a stable cloud (gas giant, planet, pre-ignition star, whatever you call it).
so to form a planet, you need a certain minimum mass to kickstart the process: a solid or liquid mass (like an asteroid) that does not have internal pressure driving it apart, and that provides the initial gravity force to attract more gas, which then contributes to the gravity field and so on.
so each planet has to have a rock inside of it, that originally started the planet-forming mass accumulation. so we should find a solid or liquid core inside every planet or star.
So… a few things. You’re kind of right about a few things, but also not exactly, and wrong about stars altogether.
A) The first stars were formed from hydrogen. They formed without rocky materials because there were no rocky materials before stars. There was no helium before stars for that matter. At a certain scale gravity does in fact compress gasses enough to form a single body and get so hot and dense and such high pressure in the process that they start fusing those atoms together to form other elements. That fusion is where those heavier elements come from in the first place. Most stars absolutely do not have rocky or liquid cores. Active stars have plasma cores. Dead stars like white dwarfs or neutron stars that shredded their outer layers after burning out their hydrogen are now more or less liquid/solid masses of exotic matter and dense neutron matrices, though.
B) Gas giants like Uranus and Jupiter are almost entirely hydrogen and helium too. But both of them started with a solid core that gathered gas around them. So you’re kind of right there. But it wasn’t formed from “rocks” per se.
C) You do need a solid mass to form a planet, yes. But that start is not an asteroid because an asteroid is not a starting point. Stars aren’t spitting out asteroids whole. Asteroids and planets form the same way. They are the gravitational collection of star dust, i.e. individual particles of heavier elements from helium to iron, etc. that are blasted across space when a star goes supernova.
Those particles collide and slow one another, and clouds of dust form together in the vacuum of space until enough collects for gravity to clump then into a small mass which collects more dust as it collides with it. Eventually enough collects to have a gravitational pull on other such clumps and loose dust and those eventually collide and collect too adding their gravitational pull to the mass. If this happens enough, object gets large enough to have pulled in all other such bodies and dust in its way that you end up with a round body that’s cleared its orbital path. That is a planet. They can have wildly different traits but that that is the definition of a planet.
Asteroids are not planets because they are still too small and mostly not round because of their size. Dwarf planets aren’t normal planets because they’re also too small to have cleared their orbital paths of debris. But they all started as dust of heavier elements than hydrogen and helium.
Where did that rock come from? The universe started as a cloud.
So you’re half right. It does take extra mass, but at some point that cloud of dust accumulates enough mass to exert enough gravity to condense into a solid object.
Remember, planets don’t form on their own, they form as part of a solar system. A cloud of dust rotates, forms a star at the densest part, then the remaining dust rotates and forms a disc, then different parts collapse into planets. The type of planet that forms is dependent on the distribution of dust in the disc. Dense spots become gas giants, less dense become ice giants, lesser still become rocky planets, and the least dense become dwarf planets. Dust that isn’t dense enough to form planets gets swept up or blown away, or might form an asteroid belt depending on how it’s influenced by local bodies.
https://www.amnh.org/exhibitions/permanent/the-universe/planets/formation-of-our-solar-system
It’s discs all the way down.
- gasses and clouds have mass, and with a large enough mass the cloud will in fact compress despite internal pressure.
- planets are not made of hydrogen. They are made from heavier elements that have been fused inside an earlier generation of stars.
- planets are not made of hydrogen.
Maybe not exclusively, but certainly majorly: 90 % of Jupiter’s mass is hydrogen.
Prefacing with, I am not an expert at all.
But large rocks would have to come from somewhere. In the lack of a greater source of gravity, dust particles would likely drift together over time, forming a rock and larger.
I’m not certain where the dust would originate, but it seems logical that some other chemical reaction is probably the source?
At least that’s my reasoning. I’d have to do some research to see if it’s accurate
you need a molten core of iron and other heavily elements. usually comes from things like a massive star or supernova remenants.



