Scenario A:
Bob decides not to have kids. Bob grows old and dies without kids.
Scenario B:
Bob does not have any kids. Bob hangs himself in his garage.
These are not the same thing. Humanity going extinct because everyone decided not to reproduce at the same time is also not the same thing as humanity going extinct because they all jump into a volcano simultaneously.
You can enjoy being here and also not have kids. It’s actually trivial how much not the same these things are.
I completely agree, and I see it exactly the same way. That’s also the path I’m choosing for myself. I think the main problem is that many people are so attached to certain societal ideals that they build their entire identity around having a partner, getting married, and having children. They genuinely seem to believe that you’re somehow missing out on life or that your life is incomplete if you don’t have those things. But that’s simply not true. You can enjoy life, find meaning, be happy, and feel fulfilled without wanting a partner or children. Not everyone shares the same goals, and not everyone needs to follow the same life script. Choosing not to have children is not the same as rejecting life itself.
I do not care if ssfckdt personally extends their lineage or not and this fact is not remotely related to what I am criticizing. I don’t even have kids.
Let’s lay out how this conversation has progressed:
ssfckdt:
Frankly we’d probably be doing the planet a big favor by ceasing to perpetuate ourselves
You:
I choose life, ssfckdt, but that’s because I enjoy being here.
ssfckdt:
What I find weird here is that I was talking about ending reproduction, and you somehow interpreted that as individual su*cide. Like, if you don’t reproduce, you cease to exist? Huh?
You:
Because these are the same thing.
It really does look like you’re saying that not having children is equivalent to suicide. And if you believe that, “I enjoy being here” implies “I shouldn’t commit suicide,” then it looks like you should also believe that “I enjoy being here” implies “I shouldn’t (not have children).”
Then I find it confusing when you say that “You can enjoy being here and also not have kids,” is not remotely related to what you’re criticizing, because I’m explicitly piecing together things that you have already said in this conversation.
You’re not reading between the lines. I’m arguing with an anti-natalist, not someone who had a hysterectomy.
Try thinking about this for a moment, okay: What emotional state do you think a person might need to have to also fantasize about letting humanity, of which they are a part of, burn out completely?
Now compare: A person is having too much fun traveling the country and doesn’t think now, if ever, is a good time for having kids. Truthfully, they’re not sure they even want them.
Okay, I thought about it… and this is still wrong:
Because these are the same thing.
I’m telling you why what you said is wrong. ssfckdt could be criminally insane, and it wouldn’t make you any less wrong. Your wrongness has nothing to do with the emotional state of the person you responded to.
I’m arguing with an anti-natalist
I understand. You’re wrong in this context. It’s still possible for you to be wrong, even if you’re disagreeing with someone else who is also wrong. By telling you that you’re wrong, I’m not making any claim about what ssfckdt said.
Yes, it does. Advocating for the end of reproduction to… “save” the planet? is a suicidal impulse, same as trying to hasten the conditions for the rapture to happen would be. This is death cult behavior.
Whether or not you’re wrong depends on the emotional state of the person you’re responding to, “Yes it does”?
Whether or not telling you that you’re [edit: wrong] implicitly makes a claim about ssfckdt’s statements, “Yes it does”?
Neither of those work. Maybe you meant something else?
Advocating for the end of reproduction to… “save” the planet? is a suicidal impulse
See the previously outlined difference between scenario A and scenario B. Those are not equivalent. Do they become equivalent if everyone does that at the same time? No.
They’re not the same. That’s just a fact; I don’t know what else to tell you.
Honestly, I don’t think you’re equipped to have this conversation, man. You don’t seem to understand much of what I mean by suicidal, like, at all.
Can we try something? Can you explain to me in your own words what it is you think my position is? Like, you don’t agree with it, clearly, but why am I saying the words that I’m saying?
Why is it that I am so fixated on this idea that anti-natalists—I’ll be more careful with my language here—represent a suicidal, self-destructive, pessimistic and hopeless ideology and worldview?
I’m responding to a logical claim, not a moral one. petrol_sniff_king said that “ending reproduction” is the same thing as “individual suicide”. I’m pointing out that this is not true.
If you think we should keep reproducing, these are not the same thing. If you think we should stop reproducing, these are still not the same thing. I’m not making a claim about whether ssfckdt is right or wrong… I’m saying that petrol_sniff_king is wrong.
Because these are the same thing. You just don’t like the way the other one sounds.
You believe that humanity is a net evil, however, you don’t want them to die now, but later? Genuinely, what the fuck are you talking about?
These are not the same thing. Humanity going extinct because everyone decided not to reproduce at the same time is also not the same thing as humanity going extinct because they all jump into a volcano simultaneously.
You can enjoy being here and also not have kids. It’s actually trivial how much not the same these things are.
I completely agree, and I see it exactly the same way. That’s also the path I’m choosing for myself. I think the main problem is that many people are so attached to certain societal ideals that they build their entire identity around having a partner, getting married, and having children. They genuinely seem to believe that you’re somehow missing out on life or that your life is incomplete if you don’t have those things. But that’s simply not true. You can enjoy life, find meaning, be happy, and feel fulfilled without wanting a partner or children. Not everyone shares the same goals, and not everyone needs to follow the same life script. Choosing not to have children is not the same as rejecting life itself.
I do not care if ssfckdt personally extends their lineage or not and this fact is not remotely related to what I am criticizing. I don’t even have kids.
Let’s lay out how this conversation has progressed:
ssfckdt:
You:
ssfckdt:
You:
It really does look like you’re saying that not having children is equivalent to suicide. And if you believe that, “I enjoy being here” implies “I shouldn’t commit suicide,” then it looks like you should also believe that “I enjoy being here” implies “I shouldn’t (not have children).”
Then I find it confusing when you say that “You can enjoy being here and also not have kids,” is not remotely related to what you’re criticizing, because I’m explicitly piecing together things that you have already said in this conversation.
You’re not reading between the lines. I’m arguing with an anti-natalist, not someone who had a hysterectomy.
Try thinking about this for a moment, okay: What emotional state do you think a person might need to have to also fantasize about letting humanity, of which they are a part of, burn out completely?
Now compare: A person is having too much fun traveling the country and doesn’t think now, if ever, is a good time for having kids. Truthfully, they’re not sure they even want them.
Okay, I thought about it… and this is still wrong:
I’m telling you why what you said is wrong. ssfckdt could be criminally insane, and it wouldn’t make you any less wrong. Your wrongness has nothing to do with the emotional state of the person you responded to.
I understand. You’re wrong in this context. It’s still possible for you to be wrong, even if you’re disagreeing with someone else who is also wrong. By telling you that you’re wrong, I’m not making any claim about what ssfckdt said.
Yes, it does. Advocating for the end of reproduction to… “save” the planet? is a suicidal impulse, same as trying to hasten the conditions for the rapture to happen would be. This is death cult behavior.
Yes it does what?
Whether or not you’re wrong depends on the emotional state of the person you’re responding to, “Yes it does”?
Whether or not telling you that you’re [edit: wrong] implicitly makes a claim about ssfckdt’s statements, “Yes it does”?
Neither of those work. Maybe you meant something else?
See the previously outlined difference between scenario A and scenario B. Those are not equivalent. Do they become equivalent if everyone does that at the same time? No.
They’re not the same. That’s just a fact; I don’t know what else to tell you.
The first one.
Honestly, I don’t think you’re equipped to have this conversation, man. You don’t seem to understand much of what I mean by suicidal, like, at all.
Can we try something? Can you explain to me in your own words what it is you think my position is? Like, you don’t agree with it, clearly, but why am I saying the words that I’m saying?
Why is it that I am so fixated on this idea that anti-natalists—I’ll be more careful with my language here—represent a suicidal, self-destructive, pessimistic and hopeless ideology and worldview?
The thing is most of us don’t want that, only sickos do.
I’m responding to a logical claim, not a moral one. petrol_sniff_king said that “ending reproduction” is the same thing as “individual suicide”. I’m pointing out that this is not true.
If you think we should keep reproducing, these are not the same thing. If you think we should stop reproducing, these are still not the same thing. I’m not making a claim about whether ssfckdt is right or wrong… I’m saying that petrol_sniff_king is wrong.