Obviously know actual slavery was way way worse, as there was awful abuse, terrible living conditions, no freedom of expression or obtaining goods. BUT - If the premise of current society is that adults have to work until they have earned their freedom (earned enough money to retire) - that’s slavery. I don’t think people really internalise that for what it is.
You’re not allowed to go grow vegetables in a forest. You are forced to produce value for others because other people have claimed the land you need to sleep and grow food. They have no actual right to it. The people who first claimed it were probably not even the first people there, they were just the people violent enough to fight anyone that said it wasn’t theirs.
Slavery is slavery? No way
“Chattel” slavery might be a helpful term
I mean on the one hand, sure
On the other hand, slave-owners sort of had to actually make sure you had food, shelter, and healthy enough to sustain their workforce. Wal-mart don’t give a fuck if you have to sleep in your car and can’t make rent, show up in uniform and don’t complain or they will take the next desperate person and you risk being arrested for violating modern vagrancy laws.
People can interpret that how they will.
It’s almost like they’re offloading the cost of slave owning to the government.
You might even go further and say that capitalists in the 17th and early 18th century openly talked about how slavery was increasingly an inferior form of control. That with industrialization and urban concentration dragged down capital accumulation for capitalists and that in fact precarity of unemployment, starvation, loss of social status, and the ability to easily replace their workforce and offload the burdens you speak of was a cheaper and equally effective way to reproduce the same functional exploitation.
People can interpret that how they will.
This is not a matter of interpretation. Wall-Mart employees are citizens; legal humans with rights and access to the court system. Also there is the small difference that Wall-Mart doesn’t own it’s employee’s children and they’re not, in turn, required to work for Wall-Mart into perpetuity.
Sure, and further interpretation would be that the severing of any sort of responsibility for guaranteeing the material conditions of their workforce knowing that absent selling their labor, a individual risks precarity thus ensuring a steady pool of cheap, readily available labor, which increasingly became seen as a feature for capitalists, not a bug.
And that said court system, along with other tools of coercion and control within the state, were directly designed and structured by the ruling class to protect their class interests and sustain the necessary reproduction of exploitation for maintaining this system.
…obviously. that’s why they use the same words.
Wage slavery is a type of slavery, which is why it is called “slavery” with a descriptor in front of it.
A sledgehammer is a hammer.
While you still can’t plant vegetables in public space, in Sweden we have a “right of public access” that more or less enshrines foraging as a right
Lots of caveats to how far that can be taken, of course:
https://aresweden.com/en/about-are/the-swedish-right-of-public-access/
There’s no way this is an unpopular opinion on Lemmy.
Right? Go post this elsewhere. I’m here for spicy takes not to toe the lemmy line.
sir, this is Unpopular Opinion
Right? I thought he was going to drop something that would piss me off. Jeez, thanks, captain obvious.
Once at my job, I had to help a customer after I clocked out. You can read all about it in my memoir: 12 minutes a Slave. 🙃
“But people NEED to work or they’ll have nothing to do!” - everyone but us
You dont need to tack on the most extreme words to make something bad. It can be bad without being slavery and to try and lump it in with slavery is fucked up to actual slavery.
As a foreigner, this is literally exactly what I thought when I moved to the US and started working. It’s like you’re in a prison cell, but you get used to it throughout the years (which is so fucking sad), and as you progress in your “career” path. If you eventually fall into a better place and find an actual career doing something you enjoy, then it gets a lot easier. This is at least how it worked out for me. 13 years of shit work until I found that one job that I’ll die doing.
We live lives of indebted servitude.
Here I am slaving away at work, scrolling Lemmy, lol.
Total nonsense - look at both the practical horror of the reality of slavery, and the moral/ethical horror of regarding another a human being as property. Having to work for a living (I.e. not just being given everything you want) is not remotely comparable to being a slave.
As the first teaching of Buddhism says:
Life involves suffering



